top of page
  • Writer's pictureKelly

The Consequences of Leadership Inconsistency

When Words Don't Match Actions

When employees make mistakes or fail to meet expectations, a natural response for many managers is to address the issue directly with the employee. However, before leaders jump into corrective mode, it's essential to step back and evaluate whether they, as leaders, are truly embodying the values and expectations they've set for their teams.

One of the most damaging scenarios in a workplace is when leaders communicate one message and act in opposition to it. For example, leaders who emphasize a "no-blame" culture but subsequently chastise employees for errors are not just being inconsistent; they're eroding trust, morale, and potentially the very fabric of the team's culture.

Leading by example isn't just a catchphrase; it's a foundational principle for effective leadership. If managers stress the importance of punctuality but often arrive late themselves, or if they advocate for open communication but are rarely available for feedback, these discrepancies become glaringly evident to their teams. Over time, such inconsistencies can lead to a perception of insincerity or, worse, hypocrisy.

When employees witness a gap between what's said and what's done, several negative outcomes can arise:

1. Decreased Trust: Trust is built on consistency. When leaders don't walk the talk, employees may start to question the authenticity of any of their future communications or commitments.

2. Lowered Morale: If employees feel that they're held to a different standard than their leaders, it can lead to resentment. Such feelings, when left unaddressed, can sap the enthusiasm and drive out of even the most passionate employees.

3. Reduced Engagement: Employees look to their leaders as role models. If they perceive a lack of commitment or inconsistency from the top, they might question why they should hold themselves to a higher standard.

4. A Culture of Fear: If leaders verbally promote a safe environment for mistakes but then punish errors, employees may become overly cautious. This fear-driven approach can stifle innovation and risk-taking, both crucial for growth.

For leaders to effectively guide their teams through mistakes and shortfalls, they must first ensure they are consistently exemplifying the standards they set. This doesn't mean leaders can't make mistakes themselves; after all, they are human. However, it does mean that when they falter, they should acknowledge it, learn from it, and demonstrate accountability.

In essence, the ripple effect of leadership inconsistency can have far-reaching consequences. It's not merely about preventing missteps but about fostering an environment where both leaders and employees are aligned in values, actions, and expectations. In such a harmonious setting, mistakes become opportunities for growth, and every challenge is met with collective resilience and adaptability. Leaders, remember that your actions often speak louder than your words; ensure they're sending the message you truly intend.

9 views0 comments


bottom of page